Wednesday, April 2, 2014

A New Metaphor



It has been a rough year. I take a deep breath every time I start to talk about this year, about the mood of anxiety and depression that has become palpable in this department. My desire for oxygen functions as a reminder of the embodied realities of stress and sadness, the necessity of some sort of physical preparation for another encounter with it all. It has been an emotional year, and I don’t just mean for me; that would be too simple. Emotion has become the medium through which I experience this place and my role within it. In Doing Emotion: Rhetoric, Writing, and Teaching, Laura Micciche “looks at emotions as emerging relationally, in encounters between people, so that emotion takes place between bodies rather than residing in them” (13). And though I might have believed in such a theorization of emotion before now, this year has made such a conceptualization manifest. It now feels lived. Micciche expands on this idea arguing that “emotion is dynamic and relational, taking form through collisions of contact between people as well as between people and the objects, narratives, beliefs, and so forth that we encounter in the world” (28). These emotionally-inflected collisions of contact feel apparent in conversations with colleagues, in the moments I open my email, and in the time I spend staring at budgets and the spreadsheet of comments on candidates for a recently-failed search. 

A recent graduate of the doctoral program dropped by to visit a couple weeks ago and said she could feel the low morale of the department, that we all looked “worn thin” and exhausted. She remarked on never before seeing so many doors closed. I joked that we had all retreated to our caves to lick our wounds, my use of metaphors of war and wounded animals feeling too accurate even in a joke. I have been thinking a lot about metaphors lately. As Micciche explains, there is a long and storied history of metaphors in the field of composition and rhetoric. As Lakoff and Johnson (1980), the foundational figures in contemporary critical metaphor analysis have argued, metaphors change our conception of reality. Still, Micciche argues that “these changes are due not to the workings of metaphor alone, but also to the circulation of feeling through metaphor, an adhesive that binds metaphor to bodies, objects, experiences and perceptions. Metaphors accrue a certain amount of stickiness through repetition and circulation, shaping constructions and perceptions of reality while creating affective spaces” (38). 

The dominant metaphors in the field are ones of subjugation and subordination; writing teachers and writing program administrators are regularly described as maids, servants, gypsies, and basement dwellers. Our scholarship for decades has emphasized our marginalized positions through the use of metaphor. Micciche does not discount the truth value of this sort of marginalization, but she questions the emotional and political consequences of these dominant disciplinary metaphors. She draws on Wendy Brown’s concept of “wounded attachments” to do this. Micciche explains that “wounds are evidence of violence and can signify physical places of damage. A wound presents a physical, mental, and political place and injury. It functions as an authenticating pain that is both a point of contention and a site of shared identity,” but at times “political identity claims are hindered by attachments to pain and marginality, which operate as tropes for what binds people together” (39). Her text questions the way that this pain and marginalized position is often fetishized (and I might even say romanticized). Micciche wonders at what might be possible with other metaphoric orientations. She explains that “Because metaphors shape the ways in which we see ourselves and conceive the work of the field, we should consider how to construct metaphors for composition in renewed language that resists positioning ourselves as principals of our own subjection” (41). 

Reading her essay, I was struck by how difficult this notion was. Though we as a field surely want to escape the metaphoric positions of marginalization, it was striking that I couldn’t easily imagine another metaphor for what we might be. It wasn’t until much later in her book, in her chapter on “Disappointment and WPA Work” that one alternative vision finally came to me, a rather apt and discipline appropriate one even—the essayist, the one who tries.  Perhaps this is a conception that bridges the hope and disappointment, the two emotional experiences of the field that Micciche focuses on throughout the chapter. Micciche, working from Richard Miller, argues that  “WPAs must choose to act in the face of despair and hopeless, knowing full well that the changes one would most like to implement may never come to pass” (85). And in many ways, this is what the essayist does. I always share with my students the etymology of the word “essay,” its roots in the French essayer meaning “to attempt” or “to try.” I tell my students that the word itself contains the inevitability of failure and disappointment but hazards forth in spite of this. I think the essayist is hopeful but melancholic, aware of always-existing failure, and perhaps that is the emotionally-charged metaphor that we might work with. 

I have recently been critical of hope; its Messianic promise makes me nervous. But perhaps it is more essayistic in energy than I give it credit for; perhaps it, too, foresees failure.  Micciche explains that “hope is an act of mutuality—an act of collaboration between members of a community. It is collaborative in the sense that one’s vision for what might be is within the realm of the possible in a given community” (88). She continues suggesting that “disappointment, in contrast, develops from a sense of hopelessness stemming from the impossible, or from what is made to seem impossible. From this perspective, disappointment is a failure of imagination” (88). Here, I would disagree with Micciche. I don’t see hope and disappointment as contrasting or stemming from opposite direction. Might it be more productive to see them as parallel? Wouldn’t this be the more essayistic reading of the emotional experience of the field?  

Wednesday, January 22, 2014

Rhetorics and Disciplines of Crisis

My application for doctoral studies at the University of Nebraska began with James Berlin’s axiomatic argument that “to teach writing is to argue for a version of reality” (766). Berlin locates the unique (and rather frightening) position one occupies when one steps in front of a class of students. Though teaching is  often seen by the larger public, and even by those in the profession, as a relatively neutral vocation,  Berlin is clear that teaching is a complex rhetorical activity involving the dissemination of social and political ideologies  and historically and culturally-situated epistemologies. As a scholar of writing instruction, it only seems appropriate to return to Berlin now as I begin the process of composing my reading lists for comprehensive exams, to consider the realities I argue for in my classrooms and to consider the ways in which scholarship on the teaching of writing argues for its own version of reality, its own version of the history of the profession.

Early on in Rhetoric and Reality: Writing Instruction in American Colleges, 1900-1985, Berlin channels John Berger by stating that “A way of seeing, after all, is a way of not seeing” (7). Berlin begins here in order to posit that “as we instruct students in attending to particular orders of evidence…we are simultaneously discouraging them from seeing other orders of evidence,” and he explains that “Our decision, then, about the kind of rhetoric we are to call upon in teaching writing has important implications for the behavior of our students—behavior that includes the personal, social, and political” (7). I thought about this early comment repeatedly as I worked through Berlin’s now-canonical history of the discipline. And beyond this, as I moved through the book, I began to consider the ways in which historical and cultural moments shape the rhetorics (and the  pedagogical counterparts of those rhetorics) we call upon.  I became especially interested in this question in Berlin’s final chapter discussing the “literacy crisis” of the 1970s following the publication of “Why Johnny Can’t Write.”  Berlin describes how “since the mid-seventies, English departments everywhere have responded to the call for more and better writing instruction” and explains that “the growth in graduate departments in rhetoric [has] been one of the responses to the demand for better writing” (182-183).

Reading this made me ask an important question: What does it mean to be a discipline invented out of crisis? And more importantly, how does the circulation of the language of crisis impact the rhetorics and pedagogies we call upon in our work, and how do rhetorics employed in time of crisis construct “versions of reality” in our classrooms?

Berlin concludes his essay by arguing that  “the writing course empowers students as it advises in ways to experience themselves, others, and the material conditions of their existence—in methods of ordering and making sense of these relationships” (189). How do students experiences themselves and order the world when our choices in what we teach are still shaped by rhetorics of crisis? And beyond the ways in which the metaphor of crisis might shape the structure of the writing classroom, I find myself asking how the identities of teachers shape those writing spaces. My wonderfully supportive chair recently said to me that it is hard to be in composition because you are routinely surrounded by people who do not want to there. Not only are our students usually enrolled in our classes only because of university requirements, but many instructors of writing courses only begrudgingly teach these courses because they HAVE to early in their career. How do these realities of the labor of composition impact the rhetorics employed? How do their visions of composition shape the versions of reality imparted to their students?

Tuesday, April 16, 2013

Writing in a World Where People Kill Each Other

  
Given that Richard Miller frames Writing at the End of the World around the tragedy of the 1999 Columbine shooting, it is depressingly and upsettingly appropriate that I write this blog post the day after the Boston Marathon bombings, the day after another traumatic eruption of violence. Miller opens with the Columbine shooting as a way to challenge the narrative of “reading’s potentially redemptive power” (4). Miller works to acknowledge that Harris and Klebold were smart students, successful in their English classes, and highly literate individuals.  Still, as Miller rather bluntly states, “They read, they wrote, they talked. And at the end of the process, they tried to kill everyone they could” (5). 

As an English major and teacher, I am not a Romantic. I have never been a believer in the redemptive power of literature. I don’t have an investment in “Great Books” or the idea that such great books might make great human beings.  That said, as I read Miller, I quickly realized that I do have a strong investment in the potentially repemptive power of writing and critical thinking. While I might not accept that reading Milton makes you a better thinker, I routinely try to convince my students that understanding the metanarrative of progress underlying a Budweiser commercial will make them better consumers and better citizens, that such literacy skills will allow them to be safer, more protected.  Miller’s text forces me to confront this assumption, too reflect on the limits of those beliefs and their problematic edges. Miller is certainly aware that he is asking his readers to do this, for he explains that “it can be quite a shock to confront the possibility that reading and writing and talking exercise almost none of the powers we regularly attribute to them in our favorite stories. The dark night of the soul for literacy workers comes with the realization that training students to read, writing, and talk in more critical and self-reflective ways cannot protect them from the violent changes our culture is undergoing” (5)

Though Miller does ask that I question my belief in literacy as a preemptive savior of some potentially violent future, he does seem to suggest that the work of literacy studies and the humanities does have some potential now. Miller explains that “If there is to be lasting hope for the future of higher education, that hope can only be generated by confronting our desolate world and its urgent, threatening realities. The only way out is through” (27). In an almost Benjaminian fashion, Miller seems to insist on an attention to the now, to a redemption of the past and the now rather than some sort of distant future. He articulates a way of living in the world rather than a promise of fixing it in the future.

I thought of Miller’s insistence that “the only way out is through” as I read a former professor’s Facebook status about the Boston Marathon bombings.  Discussing the difficulty of explaining such events to her daughter, she wrote the following:
I'm thinking, in my lifetime, how sad that I've gotten used to trying to make sense of senseless tragedy. And it doesn't get any easier. But the stakes have gotten higher, trying to make sense of this for my daughter. Today, I thought, I can't tell her that goodness, and kindness, and generosity, and love prevail, because they don't always. But, goodness and kindness and generosity and love do persist, and I want her to know that she can and should be on that side of persistence.
In many ways, it seems like persistence in the face of violence is what Miller finds himself advocating.  Late in the book, he explains, “I work at getting the students to use their writing not just as a tool for making arguments, but also as a lens for exploring complexity and a vehicle for arriving at nuanced understandings of a lived reality that is inescapably characterized by ambiguities, shades of meaning, contradictions, and gaps” (196-197). It is also a lived reality that is characterized by violence, trauma, and tragedy. While Mary Rose O’Reilley frames The Peaceable Classroom around  Ihab Hassan’s question of  “is it possible to teach English so that people stop killing each other?” (9), Richard Miller forces us to consider what it means to teach in English in a world where people do kill each other.

A “C” for Clare: Grading as the Imposition of Names



Reading a text like Denise Riley’s Impersonal Passion: Language as Affect, I am always interested in the theorists that aren’t named but seem to, in a strange way, haunt the pages of a theoretical discussion. Much like Judith Butler, to whom Riley seems especially indebted, Riley pulls heavily from Foucault, Nietzsche, and Hegel but never directly engages with Derrida.  For me, this seems strange because, much like with Butler, there seems to be a certain Derridean sensibility to Riley’s work, and her discussion of the circulation of the word beyond both referent and rhetor and her discussion of the quasi-mystical powers of the word as both medicine and poison seem so directly connected to Derrida’s theorization of the pharmakon in Dessiminations and to his extensive theorizations of naming in On the Name.

Both Derrida and Riley are interested in the strange circulating materiality of the word, a thing that we tend to conceive as immaterial, as merely theoretical. Early in her text, Riley explains that “There is a tangible affect in language which stands somewhat apart from the expressive intentions of an individual speaker; so language can work outside its official content” (5). Here, Riley describes both the materiality of language (which Derrida would discuss literally as breath, air and water) and the way that it can quickly become divorced from the intentions of person who brought it into being. She discusses how language does work beyond its intended purposes and beyond its anticipated duration. Expanding on this, Riley writes that “in its violent emotional materiality, the word is indeed made flesh and dwells amongst us—often long outstaying its welcome” (9)

I thought about these sections of Riley’s text as I was reading the later chapters specifically on naming. Though I don’t think that Riley would want to limit the types of language that have these strange circulations and violent tendencies, as a teacher, I couldn’t help but think about how grading, as an exercise of power, brings into existence a type of language that names, circulates, and can be very violent.  I think about the strangeness of grading as a sort of naming process. To use the Althusserian language that runs through Riley’s text, it functions as a type of interpellation: the grade on the paper as the hail that facilitates the construction of the subject.  Riley explains that “there is an anxiety of interpellation, in which its subject ponders incessantly to herself 'Am I that name; am I really one of those?' Her query, while it interrogates the harsh attribution, stays under its rigid impress” (15). This query almost directly describes what I observe in my students when I hand back graded papers. They seem initially confused and quickly try to locate evidence for the accuracy of a given name by scrolling through my comments and their paper as a sort of proof.  Riley describes the name as “something that I pull inside me to make it mine, drawing it in from the outside” (115), and I think that this is very often what happens for my students; they go through a process of internalizing the grade, seeing it as the name for them, for their work.

I also really like Riley’s text because it uncovers the way that this relationship to naming is always located within a system of power and one of possible resistance and submission. Riley argues that “In theory the named person submits, more or less gracefully, to this impersonality of her name, tacitly consenting to behave as if it were the personal moniker that it is not” but argues that “this notion of ‘taking on’ your name drifts too close to a supposing a deliberate choice to submit” (116). In fact, those who do naming are often in positions of social or institutional power.  It is interesting to think about the frustration and anger often voiced by teachers when students protest a grade, fail to submit, to “tacitly consent” to the labels we place on them, frustration and anger the result of someone questioning our right to name.

Wednesday, April 3, 2013

The Courage to Quit



Reading Chapter 2 of bell hooks’s  Teaching Community: A Pedagogy of Hope, entitled “Time Out: Classrooms without Boundaries,” I couldn’t help but think about how much I could relate to hooks’s articulation of the exhaustion that comes with teaching. Now in week 13 of the spring semester, I crave the break that summer will bring. hooks begins her chapter by discussing the feeling of burnout in her teaching. She writes, “I began to feel as though I was entering a prison, a closed-down space where, no matter how hard I tried, it was difficult to create positive context for learning” (13). I find myself feeling this way about my teaching these last couple weeks. At the end of the semester, with papers and my own work piling up, I find myself exhausted and annoyed at the idea of having to go into the classroom.  I agree with hooks when she argues that “The most negative consequence of this type of burnout is manifest when teachers begin to abhor and hate students” (15).  Though I am almost obnoxiously annoying with my “I love my students!” mantra, I do find myself resenting them when I approach these moments of burn out. I get annoyed at answering the same email over and over again. I throw down a paper and storm away from grading after reading yet another student who misunderstood my (likely confusing instructions).  Of course, it isn’t just me that is tired and frustrated. Today, the embodied and affective dimensions of burn-out were obvious on my students’ faces. We worked through a class today pushing through the motions but both obviously annoyed with each other at different moments.

Of course, as hooks explains, there are days like this, days where everything goes wrong, where you are pissed off and frustrated and snap, but I worry when this becomes a pattern, when I feel myself unable to snap out of such a mood. Citing Parker Palmer, hooks discusses “the way continuing to work at any vocation, but particularly teaching, when we are no longer positively engaged does violence to the self” and to our students (15). The damage that is done when one begins to resent teaching is what worries me.  hooks writes that “just as it was often emotionally difficult for students [to feels as if they were not able to give their very best], it was emotionally difficult for their…teacher” (19). I think that it is important to recognize both the bodily and emotional labor that is involved in teaching and to consider how we can develop more sustainable practices and find ways to take a moment of time out.

Of course, as a lowly instructor, I become somewhat frustrated with hooks’s ability to simply leave the comfort of her tenure-track position. It has to be acknowledged that her fame and social status allow for this. She can surely make more money on the lecture circuit than I may ever make. I think that she fails to acknowledge this as much as she should in the chapter, but I agree with her assessment of an important problem in the field: we need to figure out how we can allow ourselves time out, and we need to learn how to talk to administrators about the importance of such breaks. While I agree with hooks that “the courage to teach is the courage to keep one’s heart open in those very moments when the heart is asked to hold more than it is able” (19), we also need to recognize when the weight of our heart is becoming a burden and when those practices are causing us to close off.  Perhaps the final direction hooks points us in is “the challenge of finding and creating spaces where teaching and learning could be practices outside the norm” (23). I wonder which ways such spaces might allow us in the profession both a break from the institutional stressors of teaching and allow us to continue to do what we love. Still, it is an awkward and difficult thing. I often want to invite groups of my students out for a cup of coffee and a discussion of some text or pop culture development, but, as hooks addresses in later chapters, the institution and the professoriate, are nervous about relationships between teachers and students that transcend the walls of the institution.

A Form of Expressivism that Doesn't Make Me Feel Nauseous



As I mention in this post, I am not a huge fan of most expressivist pedagogy. Don’t get me wrong; I love personal writing, and I cannot imagine academic writing without personal investment or without narrative. What bothers me about a lot of the expressivist pedagogy is the language of “authenticity.” I am not a teacher who is invested in the theorization of my students’ “authentic” or “true” voices. Certainly, I am interested in my students’ voices and definitely think that we oppress the voices of our students, but the moment we start calling those voices “authentic,” I get a little bit nervous. I dislike the way that such language depoliticizes such discussions and avoids confronting the systematic racism, sexisim, and classism that is typically at work in such oppressive measures. I also worry that such language of authenticity is not too distant from a sort of paternalist colonialism which exoticizes and romanticizes the other in order to affirm colonial power.

Michelle Baillif’s “Seducing Composition: A Challenge to Identity Discoursing Pedagogies” works to revisit the basic tenants of expressivist pedagogies through the lens of postructuralism and critical pedagogies and allowed me to rethink my orientation to the movement. Baillif describes an emerging group of scholars which she describes as “revisionary expressivists” (78). Baillif explains that “By rejecting a conception of subjectivity as essential and innate, revisionary expressivists are able to overcome the main criticism against expressivism. They claim, alternatively, a subject that is simultaneously an expression of discourse and one who expresses discourse” (78). This conception of a student-subject as both agent of discourse and discursively constructed seems especially important to me, for it reveals the problematic nature of an American over emphasis on the autonomous and self-constructing individual. Instead, Baillif’s revisionist expressivists work to consider how students as constructed subjects are interpellated by power, discursively manufactured  and molded by the epistemologies of the classroom at that same time that they still speak, still express discourse and shape the world around them. It seems a critical form of expressivism that needs to be considered and theorized more.  Baillif explains that by “Refusing the Transcendental subject, these scholars theorize a positioned, localized subject with the capacity for self-reflexivity.” (81)

Perhaps what I see as most important about Baillif’s piece, though, is the way that she works to consider how us teachers of writing are complicit in the very matrices of power that we seek to warn our students about. Baillif insists that “We must consistently ask in what ways our pedagogy, here specifically a pedagogy of the personal, is complicit with systems of oppression” (78)  because “one can never be ‘just’ a teacher of writing; as a disciplinarian of discourses, the pedagogue does school a student in the interpretation of experience” (80) and “the ‘critical classroom’ functions hermeneutically, as it instructs the students in how to make meaning of their personal and collective experience” (80). As the liberatory promises of critical pedagogies continue to circulate, a consideration of the ways that we control and restrict our students seems valuable and necessary. Baillif seems especially useful because it considers the ways in which students both have the potential to resist systematic oppression at the same time that they are shaped by it. There is no escape, but there is work that can be done. In many ways, Baillif’s now-somewhat-old article prefigures the critiques of both critical and expressivist pedagogogies that will be put forward by queer pedagogues.