It has been a rough year. I take a deep breath every time I
start to talk about this year, about the mood of anxiety and depression that
has become palpable in this department. My desire for oxygen functions as a
reminder of the embodied realities of stress and sadness, the necessity of some
sort of physical preparation for another encounter with it all. It has been an
emotional year, and I don’t just mean for me; that would be too simple. Emotion
has become the medium through which I experience this place and my role within
it. In Doing Emotion: Rhetoric, Writing,
and Teaching, Laura Micciche “looks at emotions as emerging relationally,
in encounters between people, so that emotion takes place between bodies rather than residing in them” (13). And though I might have believed in such a
theorization of emotion before now, this year has made such a conceptualization
manifest. It now feels lived. Micciche expands on this idea arguing that “emotion
is dynamic and relational, taking form through collisions of contact between
people as well as between people and the objects, narratives, beliefs, and so
forth that we encounter in the world” (28). These emotionally-inflected
collisions of contact feel apparent in conversations with colleagues, in the
moments I open my email, and in the time I spend staring at budgets and the
spreadsheet of comments on candidates for a recently-failed search.
A recent graduate of the doctoral program dropped by to
visit a couple weeks ago and said she could feel the low morale of the
department, that we all looked “worn thin” and exhausted. She remarked on never
before seeing so many doors closed. I joked that we had all retreated to our
caves to lick our wounds, my use of metaphors of war and wounded animals
feeling too accurate even in a joke. I have been thinking a lot about metaphors
lately. As Micciche explains, there is a long and storied history of metaphors
in the field of composition and rhetoric. As Lakoff and Johnson (1980), the
foundational figures in contemporary critical metaphor analysis have argued, metaphors
change our conception of reality. Still, Micciche argues that “these changes
are due not to the workings of metaphor alone, but also to the circulation of
feeling through metaphor, an adhesive that binds metaphor to bodies, objects, experiences
and perceptions. Metaphors accrue a certain amount of stickiness through
repetition and circulation, shaping constructions and perceptions of reality
while creating affective spaces” (38).
The dominant metaphors in the field are ones of subjugation
and subordination; writing teachers and writing program administrators are
regularly described as maids, servants, gypsies, and basement dwellers. Our
scholarship for decades has emphasized our marginalized positions through the
use of metaphor. Micciche does not discount the truth value of this sort of
marginalization, but she questions the emotional and political consequences of
these dominant disciplinary metaphors. She draws on Wendy Brown’s concept of “wounded
attachments” to do this. Micciche explains that “wounds are evidence of
violence and can signify physical places of damage. A wound presents a physical,
mental, and political place and injury. It functions as an authenticating pain
that is both a point of contention and a site of shared identity,” but at times
“political identity claims are hindered by attachments to pain and marginality,
which operate as tropes for what binds people together” (39). Her text questions
the way that this pain and marginalized position is often fetishized (and I
might even say romanticized). Micciche wonders at what might be possible with
other metaphoric orientations. She explains that “Because metaphors shape the
ways in which we see ourselves and conceive the work of the field, we should
consider how to construct metaphors for composition in renewed language that
resists positioning ourselves as principals of our own subjection” (41).
Reading her essay, I was struck by how difficult this notion
was. Though we as a field surely want to escape the metaphoric positions of
marginalization, it was striking that I couldn’t easily imagine another
metaphor for what we might be. It wasn’t until much later in her book, in her
chapter on “Disappointment and WPA Work” that one alternative vision finally
came to me, a rather apt and discipline appropriate one even—the essayist, the
one who tries. Perhaps this is a
conception that bridges the hope and disappointment, the two emotional
experiences of the field that Micciche focuses on throughout the chapter.
Micciche, working from Richard Miller, argues that “WPAs must choose to act in the face of
despair and hopeless, knowing full well that the changes one would most like to
implement may never come to pass” (85). And in many ways, this is what the
essayist does. I always share with my students the etymology of the word “essay,”
its roots in the French essayer meaning
“to attempt” or “to try.” I tell my students that the word itself contains the
inevitability of failure and disappointment but hazards forth in spite of this.
I think the essayist is hopeful but melancholic, aware of always-existing
failure, and perhaps that is the emotionally-charged metaphor that we might
work with.
I have recently been critical of hope; its Messianic promise
makes me nervous. But perhaps it is more essayistic in energy than I give it
credit for; perhaps it, too, foresees failure.
Micciche explains that “hope is an act of mutuality—an act of
collaboration between members of a community. It is collaborative in the sense
that one’s vision for what might be is within the realm of the possible in a
given community” (88). She continues suggesting that “disappointment, in
contrast, develops from a sense of hopelessness stemming from the impossible, or from what is made to seem impossible. From this perspective,
disappointment is a failure of imagination” (88). Here, I would disagree with
Micciche. I don’t see hope and disappointment as contrasting or stemming from
opposite direction. Might it be more productive to see them as parallel? Wouldn’t
this be the more essayistic reading of the emotional experience of the field?